Dutch Parliament Asks Venice Commission To Investigate Family Subsidy Scandal

2021-01-27   |   by CusiGO

The Dutch Parliament on Tuesday passed a motion calling on the Venice Commission to investigate a ruling that overturned the family aid scandal of the centre right government on January 15 last year. In particular, the house of Representatives wants to know what happened to data protection and how the laws that led to accusations against thousands of families were enforced.

The Venice Commission, an advisory body of the Council of Europe, specializes in the study of the constitution, the protection of human rights and the improvement of democratic institutions, and the Dutch house of Representatives wants it to review the situation of its citizens in this regard. The scandal over the overthrow of mark Rutte’s government revealed that nearly 30000 parents, most of them of immigrant origin, The tax department wrongly accused them of defrauding the child care grant between 2014 and 2019, and in many cases they had to be in debt to repay it, but they were further discriminated against because of their origin. It has been considered illegal since 2014.

The legislative proposals put forward by the Venice Commission are usually accepted by the countries concerned. In some countries, from Albania to Mexico, from South Africa to Poland, the same is true of respect for the rule of law. The Dutch Parliament believes that it should analyze the legal protection of citizens, especially in the area of administrative law, because the parliamentary committee studying the family allowance scandal criticized the government and Parliament for “ruthlessly enforcing the rules, Not following the precepts of protecting citizens. ” There is also “the drafting of laws on unjust personal circumstances.”. At the same meeting on Tuesday, the Dutch house of Representatives approved the establishment of a national committee to review the operation of the legal system to avoid similar cases.

Pieter omtzigt, a member of the Christian Democratic Party, proposed a motion to address the Venice Committee in the house of Representatives. In 2017, he received a call from EVA Gonz á lez P é rez, a Hispanic lawyer. She exposed the family aid scandal, and members of Congress questioned the government on the case at the control meeting. Mr. omtzigt hoped that the request would be included in the next plenary meeting of the Venice Commission, scheduled for 18 March. In his view, the agency is the appropriate place to deal with this issue, “because in this scandal, the administration and the court failed, that is to say, there is a problem with our rule of law.”. In his view, there is nothing shameful about coming to the committee, as requested by France or Belgium. “It’s embarrassing that thousands of families are not protected,” Gonzalez said in a telephone conversation. The tax department cancelled the aid, sometimes because of a simple administrative mistake, while retaining the parent’s origin relationship.

Mark Rutte, the current prime minister, offered the government’s collective resignation two months after the election, promising that all families would be compensated by 30000 euros each. Soon after, the Ministry of Finance agreed that the parents’ debt to the official agencies to repay the aid would be forgiven, but the loan from the private sector would still be valid. At present, creditors, whether banks, power companies or real estate companies, refuse to forgive them so that compensation can be given to them. In the face of the coming administrative tug of war, Congress also passed a motion on Tuesday urging the government to take over the private overdraft of parents and reform the subsidy system.